Wednesday, April 2, 2008

Journal Fishing

Ok, I need to set this one up. I want to coin a new phrase... Journal Fishing

Main Entry: jour·nal
Pronunciation: \ˈjər-nəl\
Function: noun
Definition [one of the definitions]
a periodical dealing especially with matters of current interest

Main Entry: fishing
Function: transitive verb
Definition [one of the definitions]
to engage in a search by groping or feeling


MY NEW DEFINITION
Main Entry: jour·nal fishing
Pronunciation: \ˈjər-nəl\ \ˈfi-shiŋ\
Definition [my definition]
to engage in
a search for a journal to submit a previously rejected manuscript


Commentary:
I recently was asked to review an article from a journal that I had not heard of before. As I started reading the article, I recognized it as similar to one I had reviewed a year or so ago that I had reviewed as needing major revisions (I also gave several issues that needed to be addressed). Well, the more I read, the more it was not only similar but was identical. When I did a 'compare documents', the main difference was the abstract. The authors didn't even attempt to address any of the issues I had. They, instead, just went Journal Fishing. Even more sad is that the corresponding author is an upstanding and well known researcher in the field.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home

Google